On 18 October, 2015, an 18 year old student, Steven Jones, was attacked by a drunken mob of fraternity members. One member ran up to Jones and sucker punched him. Jones two friends were on the ground defending themselves. Jones ran to his car and retrieved a legally owned pistol. At least one of the fraternity member ran at Jones, who fired, killing one and wounding two others.
The incident was initially characterized as a school shooting. Jones cooperated with authorites. They charged him with first decree murder. As more evidence became available, it was learned that everyone Jones shot was legally intoxicated with alcohol. Most had traces of marijuana in their system. No alcohol or drugs were found in Jones blood.
The trial ended in a hung jury and mistrail. The judge immediately stated that Jones would face a new trial, starting on 1 August, 2017. This is a bit unusual. Prosecutor offices usually take a little time to decide whether a new trial is in the best interest of the community, or not. Judges do not make that decision. Apparently, the prosecution informed Judge Slayton of their decision before he made the announcement. From azcentral.com:
The retrial of accused Northern Arizona University shooter Steven Jones won’t happen in October because a member of his defense team is medically unable to proceed to trial at that time.The Steven Jones case is being prosecuted by the Coconino County Attorney's office. The office has not been Second Amendment friendly. It was the Coconino County Attorney's office that persecuted Harold Fish. Harold Fish spent years in prison before the Arizona Court of Appeals reversed the conviction. The Arizona legislature changed Arizona law on self defense back to what it had been, 9 years earlier, because of the Harold Fish case.
Coconino County Superior Court Judge Dan Slayton on Wednesday set a new trial date for March 27, 2018, despite objections from prosecutor Ammon Barker.
The trial had been scheduled to begin Oct. 10 after being postponed once in August.
Slayton also said there were offers made by the Coconino County Attorney’s Office that would have "significantly reduced the exposure Mr. Jones would suffer if he proceeded to trial." But Slayton said that “Mr. Jones, acting on the advice of counsel, has decidedto reject the offer and proceed to trial."
Judge Slayton had refused to allow body camera video taken at the scene, minutes after the shooting, to be shown to the jury as evidence. Here is the officer body camera video taken at the scene, minutes after the shooting.
Link to bodycam video from the scene
A motion for mistrial by the defense was refused by the trial judge, Dan Slayton. on 27 April, 2017. Slayton previously took the unusual stance of ruling the police video from the scene as "prejudicial". In the video, a bloodied and hysterical 18 year old, Steven Jones, tells the police how glad he is that they are there, and that he thought he was going to die.
Then, in the closing arguments, the prosecution claimed that Steven Jones had never claimed self defense until he was at the police station. The defense called for a mistrial over this false assertion. Judge Slayton ruled that a transcript of some of Jones statements in the video would be allowed to be shown to the jury, to offset the bad information put forward by the prosecution.
Two days later, the judge declared a mistrial due to a hung jury.
The new trial is set for 27 March, 2018.
It would seem to be a good time to have a different judge supervise the new trial.
Judge Slayton will be the judge in the new trial as well as the old one.
©2017 by Dean Weingarten: Permission to share is granted when this notice and link are included.
Gun Watch
No Hung Jury , Hang the judge. This absolutely in line with the Arizona law of self defense.
ReplyDeleteAfter watching the video all I can say is he did not shoot enough of them. Punk ass bastards Arizona law clearly allows you to shoot in self defense when you are attacked by more than one person or in fear of your life or the life of another, those ass hole just found someone that was not afraid to shoot and would not take their drunken crap.
ReplyDeleteI had just been back from Vietnam for about a year when I was driving through the park in town and my car was surrounded by well over six pot head drug punks telling me to stay out of their park. I grew up in that town and it was my park. The mouth piece of the group was yelling lots of things at me mostly how his gang was going to kick my ass. I calmly asked the mouth piece if he knew who I was. He said he didn't give a fuck who I was and I said well you should because I'm the guy holding this pistol, I was raising up with a nine and a half inch barrel, that I'm going to blow your balls off with and shoot every one of you I can. Never seen so much dust kicked up that late at night and my path through the park was now clear.
ReplyDelete